| Fred Hume | Builder | Charter Member | Deceased |
| Dan McKenzie | Builder | Charter Member | Deceased |
| Clarence "Biscuits" Peele | Field | Charter Member | Deceased |
| Clifford "Doughy" Spring | Field | Charter Member | Deceased |
| Jimmy Gifford | Field | Charter Member | Deceased |
| George Rennie | Field | Charter Member | Deceased |
| Alex "Dad" Turnbull | Field | Charter Member | Deceased |
| Bill Dickinson | Box | Charter Member | Deceased |
| Jim Douglas | Box | Charter Member | Deceased |
| Alfie Davey | Box | Charter Member | Deceased |
| Bill Wilkes | Box | Charter Member | Deceased |
| Bill Wilson | Box | Charter Member | Deceased |
| Gordon (Grumpy) Spring | Builder | 1966 | Deceased |
| Pat Feeney | Field | 1966 | Deceased |
| Tom "Sharkey" Gifford | Field | 1966 | Deceased |
| Ed Downey | Box | 1966 | Deceased |
| Ab Brown | Builder | 1967 | Deceased |
| Harold "Haddie" Stoddart | Field | 1967 | Deceased |
| Jack Wood | Field | 1967 | Deceased |
| Ray Baker | Box | 1967 | Deceased |
| Oscar Swanson | Builder | 1968 | Deceased |
| Clayton "Blackie" Black | Box | 1968 | Deceased |
| Tom Gordon | Builder | 1969 | Deceased |
| George Feeney | Field | 1969 | Deceased |
| Hugh Gifford | Field | 1969 | Deceased |
| Leonard Turnbull | Field | 1971 | Deceased |
| John Vernon | Field | 1971 | Deceased |
| Harry Carter | Box | 1971 | Deceased |
| George Friend | Builder | 1972 | Deceased |
| Ike Hildebrand | Box | 1972 | Deceased |
| Chick Anderson | Builder | 1973 | Deceased |
| Bert Bryant | Box | 1973 | |
| Cliff Sepka | Box | 1973 | |
| Jack Bionda | Box | 1974 | Deceased |
| Jack Byford | Box | 1975 | Deceased |
| Wilson "Willis" Patchell | Field | 1976 | Deceased |
| Jake Proctor | Box | 1976 | Deceased |
| Stan "Bunny" Joseph | Box | 1976 | Deceased |
| Mike Gates | Box | 1977 | Deceased |
| Pete Meehan | Box | 1977 | Deceased |
| Pete Anthony | Box | 1978 | Deceased |
| Jack Barclay | Box | 1978 | |
| Paul Parnell | Box | 1980 | |
| Mario Crema | Box | 1980 | Deceased |
| Jack Fulton | Builder | 1981 | |
| Joe Comeau | Box | 1983 | Deceased |
| Bill "Red" Fraser | Field | 1984 | Deceased |
| Bill Armstrong | Builder | 1985 | |
| Leo Gregory | Field | 1985 | Deceased |
| Wayne Goss | Box | 1986 | |
| Les Norman | Box | 1989 | |
| Doug McRory | Box | 1990 | Deceased |
| Al Lewthwaite | Box | 1991 | |
| Wayne Shuttleworth | Box | 1992 | |
| Harry Preston | Builder | 1993 | Deceased |
| Steve d'Easum | Box | 1993 | |
| Ken Winzoski | Box | 1995 | Deceased |
| Harry McKnight | Builder | 1996 | Deceased |
| Bertie Houston | Veteran Player | 1997 | |
| Dave Durante | Box | 1997 | |
| Art Pruden | Veteran Player | 1998 | Deceased |
| Skip Chapman | Box | 1999 | Deceased |
| Brian Tasker | Box | 1999 | |
| Alfie Wood | Veteran Player | 1999 | |
| William "Casey" Cook | Builder | 2000 | |
| Kerry Gallagher | Box | 2000 | |
| John Van Os | Builder | 2001 | |
| Rod Banister | Box | 2001 | |
| Eric Cowieson | Box | 2001 | |
| Bill Jobb | Veteran Player | 2002 | |
| Ben Hieltjes | Box | 2002 | |
| Geordie Dean | Box | 2003 | |
| Lew Landess | Veteran Player | 2004 | |
| Bob Tasker | Box | 2004 | |
| 1968 - 1972 New Westminster Teams | Team Category | 2004 | |
| Ivan Stewart | Box | 2005 | |